We Muslims should be appalled by the sale of halal meat by stealth


When I walk into a restaurant, I’m usually a hungry customer. It shouldn’t be important to the waiter what my religion is. 

I could be a Muslim, a Christian or a Jedi warrior. Whatever my beliefs, I have a right to enjoy my meal without any hidden agendas.

Pizza Express, one of Britain’s favourite food institutions, admitted this week that all the chicken it serves has been killed according to traditional halal methods. The blood was drained from the bird and prayers were recited during the slaughter.

Halal1

Now it turns out that the meat in many supermarkets is also halal — though there is no recognizable label to indicate this fact to consumers.

This is covert religious extremism and creeping Islamic fundamentalism making its way into Britain by the back door. It is completely wrong that the food sensitivities of Britain’s Muslims — who amount to just 4.8 per cent of the population — should take precedence over the other 95 per cent.

Halal meat should never be forced on customers without their knowing, surreptitiously and using clandestine methods. It’s unfair to everyone, non-Muslims and Muslims alike. It’s deception on a grand scale for the former, while it could fuel bitter resentment against the latter.

Of course I understand that many of my fellow Muslims, who are moderates not militants, will feel strongly that they wish to eat meat that has been killed by customary halal methods — and they have a perfect right to do so.

Halal2

But many misconceptions need to be clarified, because I am certain that most people don’t understand where these rules about food came from, and who benefits from them.

First of all, if you’ve just tucked into a chicken pizza without knowing it was halal meat, it hasn’t done you any physical harm. But it hasn’t done you any spiritual good, either. Muslims don’t believe that religious observance can be used as a holy shortcut or a ticket to paradise.

Furthermore, the idea that Muslims cannot eat non-halal food — food that is suitable for Christians — is completely wrong, and it has no theological basis in the Koran, the supreme text of Islam.

I’m a dedicated Muslim, a devout religionist, an imam and intellectual scholar of Islam, but I eat whatever food is placed before me, with the obvious exception of pork. If you’re kind enough to invite me to your home, I would eat whatever meat you chose to serve: turkey, lamb, chicken, beef … anything except pork.

This is perfectly permissible in Islam, and the crucial thing is that it doesn’t have to be halal meat. No one wants an imam to be quoting chapter and verse of the Koran over the turkey sandwiches, but it is important that everyone understands how clearcut the teaching is.

Chapter five, verse five of the Koran states: ‘This day all good things are made lawful for you. The food of the People of the Book [meaning the Jews and the Christians] is lawful for you, and your food is lawful for them …’

There are no ifs and buts about that. The Koran does expect us to be thankful for our food, however.

I teach in Oxford, and when I go to dining halls in the university, I eat what is available. I must say, I’m partial to a slice of steak.

At the point of consumption, before I put the food in my mouth, I give thanks, with a brief prayer that Muslims have been saying for more than 1,400 years.

I say: ‘In the name of God, the most Merciful, the most Gracious.’ Christian readers will recognize what I’m doing — it’s very similar to the concept of saying grace.

The Koran says we cannot eat slaughtered meat unless the name of God exclusively has been pronounced over it, not any other deity or idol.

So, it does not really matter if, when that cow or lamb was slaughtered, the abattoir workers were saying prayers or playing heavy rock music at full blast on their radios. The individual prayer just prior to actual consumption makes the meat fit — halal — to eat.

But if the Koran does not insist on what have become the customary halal methods, why are they now so prevalent in Britain? One reason is that religious zealots and theological ideologues are deliberately promoting confusion about halal to sow discord and resentment.

Halal3

‘Permitted’: Halal foods are those that Muslims are allowed to eat or drink under Islamic Shari’ah

Three of the main fundamentalist Muslim sects — the Wahhabi fanatics in Saudi Arabia, the Salafi extremists of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, and the Deobandi zealots from India-Pakistan — are foisting their fabricated notions about it down our collective throats.

Muslim fundamentalist insistence on halal meat does not come from the Koran itself — it derives from a secondary and often suspect source, called the Hadith.

The Hadith consists of the reputed sayings of the Prophet Mohammad, only compiled some 300 years after his death, and it is replete with gross contradictions and anti-Koranic statements.

We all know about Chinese whispers, and how anything can be unintentionally distorted as it goes from mouth to mouth through the generations. It’s inevitable that when words are transcribed into writing 300 years later, all kinds of differences, deviations and embellishments arise.

It is the Hadith that insists that animals must be drained of blood while still alive, and the Hadith that suggests an animal cannot be stunned before slaughter. (The Hadith is also the source used by fundamentalists to justify the stoning of criminals and the use of full face veils for women.)

BY contrast, the Koran — which Muslims believe is the unadulterated word of God — says we should be considerate of all of God’s creation. Any technology to alleviate an animal’s pain or needless suffering should naturally be used.

The Koran certainly says pork and carrion meat, such as road kill, cannot be eaten.

Blood is another prohibited food. That’s why it’s an oxymoron to talk about a halal haggis or a halal black pudding. And there is a Koranic commandment that the animal must be drained of blood — although nothing to say that this should be done while the poor beast is still living.


Halal4    

If you think about it, these rules were entirely practical health safeguards in the 7th century when the holy book was written. But the extremists’ insistence that animals today should be killed in exactly the way that they were back then isn’t just cruel and bizarre, it is grotesquely hypocritical.

They don’t use 7th-century technology themselves in their own lives. Fundamentalists are happy to cook their meat in a microwave and enjoy the comforts of modern life in the UK.

It will be hard but not impossible to reverse the current trend for halal meat, because it has become a huge, multi-billion pound business both here and abroad. From the slaughterers to the distributors to the butchers, everyone right along the food chain is exploiting the ignorance of the customer, both Muslim and non-Muslim.

In my hometown, Oxford, you can go to the local supermarket and pay perhaps £5.50 a kilo for lamb. But go to the halal shop and it’s £6.50 or £7 a kilo — even though, as we now know, the supermarket meat is probably halal too. That’s a big mark-up.

As a British Muslim — and I underline the word ‘British’ — I want to see full transparency when I go to the supermarket. I want to know the true provenance of the food I buy, and it’s essential that businesses start labelling food better and accurately.

It is high time the white, liberal, Guardian-reading classes stopped behaving like apologists and woke up. There is a fundamentalist Trojan horse in our midst, and we must take corrective action.

Antiquated customs like the insistence exclusively on the Hadith version of halal meat only serve to entrench that fundamentalism. They should be rooted out and consigned to the dustbin of history. They have no place in a modern British society, where Muslims wish to be fully integrated and part of the UK mainstream.

6 responses to “We Muslims should be appalled by the sale of halal meat by stealth

  1. I am following you from now on. I thought I was the rare one who understood what Allah decreed in the Book. I too believe this whole Halal business has made a mockery of our religion.

    • God bless you my dear. All i am doing is allowing people to seek the truth. Religious scholars are coming on board without any academic knowledge and Muslim’s look up to them only because they have memorized the Quran by heart.

      I don’t want to sound biased, it is sad what we Muslim’s are doing to Islam. I have changed my ways and eat with people of others faiths and have no problem interacting and i do out shine my faith onto others as being diverse and willing to read other scriptures so we can grow in wisdom and be inspired by what we learn.

      • I grew up eating with people of other faiths and creeds. Even facing someone eating a juicy piece of pork chop! No offence what so ever. Sadly the Arabization of Islam and the over zealousness of the teachers have meant that the gentle ways of the religion I grew up with is no more. Asia is now infiltrated by zealots. As soon as I started searching deep in my heart and travelling the world as a working expat, I realised that eating ‘Halal’ was a little bullshit. As you mentioned, eating clean food was imperative. For me it was seeking out organic and as free range animal meat as possible. I think Allah doesn’t want his animals to suffer for our service (food) and so why should I not agree with the stunning method?

      • Wonderfully said. Sadly to say the Muslim’s scholars will continue to control people and psychologically make believe it’s God’s ruling or Mohammed’s.

        As being a moderate Muslim, i integrate within all faiths and enjoy my life with good intentions from the Heart. I drink and share my food with all faiths as well as they do.

        Sometimes we humans need to live our life’s using basic common sense without the psychological oppression of believing in man made ruling in order to control Muslims.

        I am going through a divorce from my Muslim wife due to re-announcing my faith in Christ. I am still a Muslim. I have been banished from my little son’s life who is 7 yrs old.

        As tradition dictates Muslim men don’t fight for their kids, they just move on and get more wives.

        But this moderate Muslim will fight for his son and give the right to my son to see his much loved father. It has been a long journey and slowly making progress and my Ex Wife Islam dictate she must in her powers to keep the child away from the father as i am judged to be a dis-believer.

        I will follow what is true even thou i maybe the only one following it. Stay firm in your wonderful beliefs and the light will shine on you.

        Take Care x

      • I’m so sorry to hear about your upcoming divorce. As a believer in LOVE and PEACE I get very upset to hear of marriage break ups and especially when the struggle affects the parenting and child care.

        What do you mean you’re still a Muslim and yet re announced your faith in Christ? Muslims are supposed to believe in Prophet Isa anyway, just not as Christ the Saviour or Son of God (part of the Trinity).

      • Salaam, So sorry i did not get back to you. I have been working on an important project at
        my work. I will try to answer your question and i hope i do not confuse you.

        It has been a long journey for me in finding out the truth rather than following our fore-fathers
        in believing what we have been indoctrinated into.

        Unfortunately my 7 yrs old will go through this.
        But i am not going to fight it, but show him my way of living and encourage him to get along with
        other faiths by sharing and giving.

        Lets so how you understand this :

        Muslim meaning is Believer.

        Islam does not mean peace like many scholars have mentioned and Muslim’s about.

        Islam meaning is “Submission”. Now from the Quran’s concept, whoever submit’s to the oneness
        of god and believes in the last day is a “Believer”.

        Let’s be open minded here and think out of the box. Whatever faith we are in, whoever believes
        in the above is a Muslim.

        It is sad how the Arabic word Muslim have been tarnished and isolated to only one sect. We are all Muslim’s if we believe in the oneness of god, no difference to the Christianity faith.

        I follow Jesus Christ, as not only a prophet of God but also the Messiah. I was indoctrinated
        into Islam without having any knowledge of what is the relationship between God and Jesus.

        I fearfully have read the Bible and go to the Church. The fear i had I thought i was blaspheming my religion Islam with all the sharia law ruling. I do not judge nor assume.

        I put myself out in the fore-front amongst the christians in order to understand the attribute given to Jesus “Son of God” and also understand the Trinity.

        I have complied an article for you which i have just published. Please take a Logical view towards it and please assist me in where i am going wrong :

        I do see myself has a Muslim Christian, meaining “Believing Christian”.

        https://wiki-islam.org/2014/06/03/why-do-christians-call-jesus-the-son-of-god/

        https://wiki-islam.org/2014/06/08/the-trinity-in-the-quran/

        Once again so sorry for the late response. Would love to speak to you.

        You are free to call me or email me on :

        salman@comms-networks.com
        Mobile : 0753 3220241
        Home : 01530 3220241

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s